Examples You’re Using Rationalization as a Defense Mechanism & How to Challenge It

Have you ever made an excuse for yourself or someone else? Most of us have! This is one way rationalization can show up as a defense mechanism in our lives. It can happen subconsciously when we genuinely believe our excuse or justification is valid.

Rationalization is a frequently used defense mechanism in which we justify behaviors, thoughts, or feelings in a more logical or socially acceptable way, even if they are not objectively rational. We employ rationalization to protect our self-esteem, creating less dissonance and making us feel less conflicted. It can temporarily relieve cognitive dissonance and uncomfortable feelings. Still, it's important to remember that these benefits are short-lived. In this article, I'll go over common ways folks use rationalization and ways to get curious and challenge this defense when it comes up. 

Common examples you're using rationalization as a defense mechanism:

*Of course, things are not always black and white; things may fall more into a grey area. Please take these examples with nuance, as we are all multifaceted human beings.

Behavioral rationalization

1. Procrastination: "I'll start working on this project later because I work better under pressure."

2. Justifying Lying: "I lied to protect someone's feelings; it was for their own good."

3. Ignoring Responsibility: "It's not my fault that I missed the deadline; the circumstances were beyond my control."

4. Rationalizing Unhealthy Behavior: "I can quit anytime I want; I'm not really addicted."

5. Ignoring Health Warnings: "I'll start eating healthier and exercising regularly tomorrow; I'm not at risk for any health problems right now."

Cognitive rationalization 

1. Confirmation Bias: "I only pay attention to information that confirms my existing beliefs because it's more reliable."

2. Stereotyping: "I believe all politicians are corrupt because that's been my experience with the ones I've encountered."

3. Denial of Evidence: "I reject scientific evidence on climate change because it conflicts with my political beliefs."

4. Just World Fallacy: "Bad things only happen to people who deserve it; it helps me feel secure in an unpredictable world."

5. Rationalizing Ignorance: "I don't need to learn about this topic because it's not relevant to my life."

6. Minimizing Cognitive Dissonance: "I support this policy even though it contradicts my previous beliefs because it benefits me personally."

7. Selective Memory: "I remember only the positive aspects of my past relationships because dwelling on the negatives would make me feel bad."

Emotional rationalization 

1. Anger: "I have every right to be angry because they mistreated me."

2. Jealousy: "It's natural to feel jealous; it just shows how much I care about them."

3. Sadness: "I'm not crying because I'm weak; I'm just feeling overwhelmed right now."

4. Fear: "I'm not afraid of failure; I'm just being cautious and considering all the risks."

5. Guilt: "I feel guilty for what I did, but I had no other choice at the time."

6. Envy: "Feeling envious is normal; it's natural to want what others have."

How to tell if you are using rationalization as a defense mechanism?

Ask yourself these questions—

Are you feeling defensive?

Notice yourself becoming defensive or emotionally reactive when someone questions your words or actions. It may be a sign of rationalization.

Are you ignoring contrary evidence?

There is a confirmation bias in rationalization where you may not be looking at all the sides; if you find yourself only looking for claims and evidence that supports your position, that can be something to be aware of

Are you making excuses?

Rationalizations involve justification; be mindful of the reasons you're assigning to your choices and whether they are aligned with your values.

Are you minimizing consequences?

Rationalization may cause you to minimize the negative consequences, justify your actions, and magnify the rewards. 

Are you feeling guilty or uneasy?

Sometimes, when you engage in a defense mechanism, it may not feel settled emotionally, which may be an invitation to invite curiosity to explore why that is.

Are you seeking validation from others?

When rationalizing, a part of you may know what you're doing is not objective. Thus, your psyche may look externally for others to affirm your behavior. 

If you answer yes to some of these questions, you might be using rationalization as a defense mechanism. It's important to be mindful of the cognitive and emotional process when making a decision. Asking yourself these questions and being honest will increase your awareness of when rationalization may be deployed, which can help lead you to more authentic, healthy choices. 

If you need more support in your mental health, feel free to learn more about my approach to therapy and contact me for a free consultation today.

More like this